Monday, January 28, 2013

Cheap Grace


Sermon 3 in Portraits of Grace Sermon Series
Sunday, January 27, 2013 Preached at FBC, Cornelia

Scripture:  Galatians 2:17-21
17 But suppose we seek to be made right with God through faith in Christ and then we are found guilty because we have abandoned the law. Would that mean Christ has led us into sin? Absolutely not! 18 Rather, I am a sinner if I rebuild the old system of law I already tore down. 19 For when I tried to keep the law, it condemned me. So I died to the law—I stopped trying to meet all its requirements—so that I might live for God. 20 My old self has been crucified with Christ.[e] It is no longer I who live, but Christ lives in me. So I live in this earthly body by trusting in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me. 21 I do not treat the grace of God as meaningless. For if keeping the law could make us right with God, then there was no need for Christ to die.
  
Portrait of Grace:  Fantine Arrested/Fantine Dying

Setting:  In the police station, then in the hospital of Montreuil-sur-Mer
Time:  1821, 7 years after Bishop Myriel gives Jean Valjean the silver candlesticks
Characters: Fantine:  A young working class woman in Paris who falls in love with an upper class rogue who deserts her.  She returns to her hometown, but to avoid the stigma of her daughter’s illegitimacy she leaves her (Cosette) with a family.  She works in Valjean’s factory until a foreman with the knowledge of Valjean fires her based on the jealous gossip of co-workers.  To provide for her daughter, Fantine sacrifices everything:  her hair, her teeth and her body.
Monsieur Madeleine (The Mayor) = Jean Valjean:  After Valjean receives the silver candlesticks, he begins a new life under this assumed name.  He invents a new manufacturing process which makes him a very wealthy man.  He builds factories to employ honest workers as well as a hospital and a school to help the poor.  He is so highly respected in the town, he is elected mayor. 


Scene:  Fantine has been arrested for prostitution by Inspector Javert.  She confronts Monsieur Madeleine in the police station.  After this arrest, Fantine becomes very sick and stays in the Mayor’s hospital.  The last part of the scene occurs in the hospital.  As Fantine dies, she sings to her daughter Cosette.


**I'm thankful to be able to show a video of the actual performance of the scene from Sunday's worship service.  Thanks to Carrie Trotter for videoing the scene].  

[A special thanks to Zack Smagur and Jane Marie Price for sharing their musical and dramatic talents with us today.  Both Zack, senior, and Jane Marie, junior, attend Habersham Central High School where they have been involved in the choral and drama programs.   Both also frequently perform in productions presented by the Habersham Community Theatre.  We know God has great plans for both of them!]



 Sermon
This scene reminds of my friend Ricky in high school.  To officially confirm my geeky status in high school, Ricky and I had conversations about grace around the table in the lunchroom.  We just didn’t call it grace.

Here’s what Ricky would tell me:  “I can do whatever I want on Friday nights – drinking, parties, hanging out with girls.  You see, this is how the whole Christianity thing works:  I can do whatever I want and then simply confess my sins.  I believe Jesus is my Savior so I am good to go.  God forgives me and I go on to next weekend.  It’s that simple.” 
“No, no, no,” I tried to argue.  “It’s more than that, really.  God wants more from us.  God desires our hearts and our lives.  Being a Christian is not a one-time event – not rituals or hoops we jump through to get God to do what we want.” 

I still remember this conversation and the ones that followed.  Ricky forced me to go to my Bible, to listen to the ancient stories, to learn what God really wants from God’s children.  Since those days I have found Ricky’s argument to be more prevalent in churches and within the Christian community than I ever imagined back in the day of parachute pants and REM.  Not that anyone comes out as forcefully and transparently as he did in high school.  Instead, we glimpse it in the ways we live.  We believe one thing in our heads, but we live another way with our lives. 

Dietrich Bonhoeffer
Dietrich Bonhoeffer labeled this reality “cheap grace” in his book The Cost of Discipleship back in 1937.  Bonhoeffer wrote with the experience of the Lutheran church in Germany during the 1930’s as his background.  He had watched the soul of the church disappear as nationalism of the Nazi party overwhelmed the purpose of the church.  The purpose of grace as the foundation of a relationship with God was lost in the fog of church and country.  Here’s how Bonhoeffer described Cheap Grace:

 “Cheap grace is the preaching of forgiveness without requiring repentance, baptism without church discipline, Communion without confession, absolution without personal confession,” says Bonhoeffer. “Cheap grace is grace without discipleship, grace without the cross, grace without Jesus Christ, living and incarnate.”

says –

Cheap grace is the arrogant presumption that we can receive forgiveness for our sins, yet never abandon our lives to Jesus.  We fall into the trap of cheap grace when we join my friend Ricky in embracing God’s forgiveness without the necessary repentance.  When we repent – we stop going one direction and choose to go in the opposite. 
When Jesus forgives someone, he say, “Your sins are forgiven, now go and sin no more.”  Cheap grace instead justifies the sin instead of the sinner and says:  Everything is forgiven, so you can stay as you are.  As Ricky said to me:  “After I confess what I’ve done - I’m good to go for next weekend.” 

To move away from cheap grace – we must attempt to recover a true understanding of the mutual relationship between grace and discipleship.

Let’s look back on this scene from Les Miserables and the Letter to Galatians for examples of cheap grace. 

After Jean Valjean receives the gift of grace – two silver candle sticks – from the bishop, his life changes.  The hatred and bitterness and hardness that defined him before were gone.  This gift allows him to become a new man.  In many ways he reinvents himself.  He becomes an industrialist.  He transforms a community by his hard word.  He tries to do good.  He starts a school and a hospital for the poor.  He treats his employees fairly. 
Yet, as Fantine sings – he fails to see her.  His failure to act on her behalf leads to her life of deep suffering and pain.  He had received grace from the bishop, but when she begged for grace from him – to let her keep her job – he failed to bestow it. 

The grace the bishop offered Jean Valjean was costly – the price of all of the silver in his home.  Yet, when Fantine begged for small grain of grace – Jean Valjean failed to even give her the time to hear her at the point of her need. 

We heard in the amazing singing of Jane Marie – the suffering and pain this lack of grace caused – in the same way we have in the weeks before – the wonder and amazement in Jean Valjean’s life when grace was extended.  Fantine forced Jean Valjean to rethink the cost of grace in his life.  We’ll hear that story next week. 
The apostle Paul relates a situation of cheap grace in the second chapter of the epistle to the Galatian churches.  He wants the Galatians to understand how easy it is to cheapen grace we’ve been given by Jesus.  So - he tells them about an encounter he had the Apostle Peter.  Yes, that Peter - the disciple, the water walker, the fisherman, the denier, the powerful preacher, and now the great leader of the NT church. 

Peter traveled up Antioch to visit and experience the great church there.  This was a special and unique church in the New Testament.  For the first time ever, this church had both Jewish Christians and Gentile Christians living in community together – worshipping, taking communion, eating together.  This is a very big deal.  Jews at this time were taught that it was against God’s law to eat and mingle with non-Jews.  Many of these Jews would have never sat down to talk or eat or fellowship with someone they considered a pagan – completely outside God’s law. 

But here in Antioch it happened because the Holy spirit offered God’s grace to everyone.  No matter your background, no matter your skin color, when the worship services were over, everyone was invited out to eat together.  The whole church was invited to share a Shoney’s hot fudge cake after Sunday evening church. 

This was the thing – in Antioch – no one thought this was wrong.  It was an expression of what God as doing in them.  Something new was happening – the spirit of God was birthing a new Church – and the believers in Antioch got to experience it.  It’s no wonder, the first place followers of Jesus were called Christians was here in Antioch.  The people outside the church saw something brand new, not Jewish or Pagan, instead little’s Christs. 
Peter comes down from Jerusalem to visit the church and he falls in love with how the barriers and laws of Judaism have been replaced by grace.  He goes to the homes of Gentile Christians, like he did with the Centurion Cornelius.  He eats their foods and shares laughs around their tables.  As a Jew, he understands, it is the grace of God that allows this to happen.  All of the Jewish Christians enjoy their Gentile Christian brothers and sisters like this.

Then, conflict happens.  A few fuddle duds – Judiazers is what the New Testament calls them – throw water on the party.  Some of the same folks who will venture up into the Galatia and corrupt the churches there – show up in the church in Antioch.  These Judiazers look down their noses at the practices of Peter and the rest of the Jewish Christians.  Christian leaders can’t eat supper with Gentile Christians – it’s against Jewish law.  To the Judiazers:  To be a Christian is to be Jewish.  The Gentiles must become Jewish to follow Jesus – the must follow the same laws.

And here, Peter falters.  Instead of standing up for the grace of Jesus and these Gentile believers – Peter backs away in fear of the Judiazers.  He stops going to eat with these Gentile believers.  And when Peter stops – the rest of the Jewish Christians in Antioch stop too.  If Peter thinks the Gentiles must become Jewish to be fully Christian than it must be right. 

This drives Paul crazy – and he calls out Peter – in front of everyone for this hypocrisy.  Listen to 2:14:  “When I saw that these [Jewish Christians] were not following the truth of the gospel message, I said to Peter in front of all the others, “Since you, a Jew by birth, have discarded the Jewish laws and are living like a Gentile, why are you now trying to make these Gentiles follow the Jewish traditions”

Said in another way – “how can you enjoy the grace of Jesus as a Jew and fellowship with Gentile Christians then demand they must become Jewish under the law.  You are enjoying grace and you are making them live under the law.”

Or in the words of Bonhoeffer- “this is cheap grace.”  By forcing the Gentiles Christians to live under the law of Moses – you say the death of Jesus Christ is not enough.  You cheapen the death and life of Jesus.

Paul calls the Christians in Galatians away from this cheap grace to the person and death of Jesus Christ.  He says in v. 21:  If keeping the law could make us right with God, then there was no need for Christ to die.

All we need is Jesus Christ.  All we need is Jesus.  We can never embrace or follow Jesus enough.  When we receive the grace of Jesus – when we accept the 2 silver candlesticks in our lives – Jesus demands not that we follow a few rules or rituals or do a few good deeds like build hospitals or schools – Jesus demands our whole life.  This is how Paul puts it to the Galatians in one of the most powerful verses of scripture:
My old self has been crucified with Christ. It is no longer I who live, but Christ lives in me. So I live in this earthly body by trusting in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.”

Rather than circumcision or ritual holidays or becoming Jewish – things that we can control - the grace of Jesus calls us to be crucified along with Jesus so that it’s not me that you see, but Jesus. 

On Wednesday, January 23 - Oswald Chambers put it this way:
“When the Spirit fills us, we are transformed, and by beholding God we become mirrors. You can always tell when someone has been beholding the glory of the Lord, because your inner spirit senses that he mirrors the Lord’s own character.” 

When our lives are abandoned to Jesus – we mirror the life of Jesus to the world.  Abandonment to Jesus defeats Cheap Grace and allows Jesus to thrive in our lives. 

Let me ask you a personal question –
  •          Have you allowed cheap grace to thrive in your life?
  •          Have you cheapened the grace of God by accepting his forgiveness only to live however you wanted?
  •         What part of your life is God calling you to abandon to Jesus today?  What needs to be crucified so that your life mirrors the life of Jesus in the world? 

Reflect on these questions as the choir prepares our hearts for communion.

No comments:

Post a Comment